Review of The Grey Chamber: Stories and Essays
Indu Ohri
José Alaniz. Resurrection: Comics in Post-Soviet Russia. Ohio State UP, 2022. Studies in Comics and Cartoons. Ebook. 248 pg. $37.95. ISBN: 9780814281925.
.
In Marjorie Bowen’s short story “A Famous Woman,” the protagonist, Tellow, grows fascinated with a statue of Gabrielle Buzot that he notices in a French village, but her history remains frustratingly unexplained to him. Tellow wonders, “surely among all those books there was some information about Gabrielle Buzot? A famous woman! What could she have been, what have accomplished to become famous? A beauty, a heroine, a great lover, a fearless patriot, a poetess?” (239). In a self-referential move, Margaret Gabrielle Vere Long—aka Marjorie Bowen—bestowed one of her names on a fictional woman whose claim to fame has been forgotten.
Like Gabrielle Buzot, Bowen’s accomplishments have been overlooked for decades, even though she published 150 novels and 200 short stories during a successful career spanning from 1906 to 1952. The result of five years of research into Bowen’s life, career, and oeuvre, John C. Tibbetts’s collection of her short stories and nonfiction, The Grey Chamber, is meant to demonstrate the versatility of her writing while still emphasizing her Weird Tales. Tibbetts has also released the first full-length scholarly study on Bowen, The Furies of Marjorie Bowen (2019), and the recent collection The Devil Snar’d: Novels, Appreciations, and Appendices (2023), which covers Bowen’s novels and critical reception. As the foremost expert on Bowen’s life and work, he builds on previous Bowen scholarship by Michael Sadleir, Edward Wagenknecht, and Jessica Amanda Salmonson in his collection. Overall, I think The Grey Chamber fulfills Tibbetts’s two goals of persuasively arguing for the recovery of Bowen’s literary works and exhibiting her writing in a variety of genres. Bowen’s modest description of her literary talents as “an inexhaustible fund of invention, a fluent and easy style, a certain gift for colour and drama, and such a passionate interest in certain periods of history that I was bound, in reproducing them, to give them a certain life” (307) holds true throughout the collection.
In the introduction, Tibbetts provides a biographical account of Bowen’s upbringing as an impoverished child with an unstable family life; despite these hardships, she succeeded through her persistence, hard work, and self-education. Bowen was a prolific author who wrote to support different family members at various times throughout her life: her abusive mother, sickly first husband, mysterious second husband, and three sons. Her works proved so popular that her historical fiction and true crime novels were adapted multiple times into well-regarded films. Along with outlining Bowen’s biography, the introduction offers literary background about her short stories and essays that Tibbetts repeats in the two forwards to each section, “Part One: Selected Short Stories” and “Part Two: Selected Essays.” Instead of repeating information found elsewhere, the introduction could have situated Bowen’s work and long career in the broader social, cultural, and historical contexts of her day. That being said, Tibbetts’s edition includes valuable paratextual materials such as a headnote before each nonfictional work, informative footnotes, and a timeline of Bowen’s life.
Part One features eighteen of Bowen’s short stories in different genres, among them ghost stories, contes cruels, social satires, historical fiction, and crime stories. Tibbetts deems her entire canon of short stories a “colossal achievement” that is “nothing less than Bowen’s own La Comédie Humaine. I can think of none of Bowen’s contemporaries—who can boast such an extensive, learned, and varied output” (32). His selections show the diversity of Bowen’s work across the aforementioned genres as well as the supernatural fiction for which she is remembered today. While the collection contains Bowen’s widely anthologized Weird Tales, I want to draw attention to her stories written in other genres. In the dreamlike fantasy “The Sign-Painter and the Crystal Fishes,” two eccentric characters are locked in mortal combat over a pair of magical fish. The dowager widower in “Madame Spitfire” evokes the ruthless women of Bowen’s true crime novels as she schemes to foil the romance between her late husband’s illegitimate daughter and her tenant. Finally, “An Initial Letter” displays Bowen’s gifts for writing historical fiction and comedy through its portrayal of members of John of Gaunt’s court (including Chaucer) as a cast of colorful medieval characters like those that inhabit the prologue of the Canterbury Tales.
Part Two presents Bowen’s essays on subjects such as Modernist women’s novels, Queen Elizabeth I’s astrologer John Dee, English royal coronations, William Hogarth’s artistry, Bowen’s unorthodox religious views, and her literary career. The essays nicely balance out the short stories in Part One by supplying her wide-ranging and unconventional opinions on different issues. The inclusion of both literary forms allows for a rich dialogue to emerge between Bowen’s views on topics such as the Weird and her representation of them in the short stories. For example, the autobiographical writings detail her childhood fear of ghosts, demons, and haunted houses, which likely explains why she often wrote about these entities in her later supernatural fiction. In her study of John Dee, Bowen observes that his communications with angels through a dubious medium, Edward Kelley, “might have been written today at any séance, save the language is more beautiful and the thought more noble than that usually employed or expressed by modern seekers after psychic knowledge” (324). Readers can trace how Bowen’s childhood fears and cultural movements such as Spiritualism shaped her Weird Tales such as “Scoured Silk,” “The Crown Plate Derby,” and “Florence Flannery.”
A comparison of the two sections uncovers a surprising contrast between the portrayal of female characters in Bowen’s short stories and her nonfictional reflections on being a woman writer in a male-dominated literary industry. This disparity suggests her complex attitude toward women’s rights: skepticism of political feminism’s effectiveness and yet sympathetic attunement to female oppression. In her memoir The Debate Continues (1939),Bowen recalls how her mother—a failed author—discouraged her from pursuing a literary career because Bowen’s first novelwas violent and tragic, which made it unsuitable for a female writer. Her stories “The World’s Gear,” “Scoured Silk,” “Madame Spitfire,” and “A Famous Woman” critique the social, financial, and professional inequities that women negotiated in the past and in Bowen’s day. The essay “Women in the Arts” celebrates Modernist women’s novels for “reveal[ing] with delicate precision the woman’s point of view, and analys[ing] with a tenderness, and yet a realism that no man could achieve, the woman’s heart, mind, and soul” (314-315). At the same time, Bowen claims that female authors such as Virginia Woolf, Dorothy Richardson, and Rosamond Lehmann lack the best male authors’ “genius.” She also insists that these authors should join the general Modernist revolt against human folly, rather than opposing “the once-proclaimed wrongs of women” (316).
Instead of remaining obscure like Gabrielle Buzot’s history, Bowen’s life, short stories, and nonfiction writings, as carefully selected and contextualized by Tibbetts, evince that her work is worth rediscovering and will reward further scholarly inquiry. This collection does a superb job of recognizing her fame as a writer of Weird Tales and highlighting her achievements in other genres. It will make Bowen’s works easily accessible to students, general readers, and scholars so that they can learn more about this once “famous woman.”
Indu Ohri is a lecturer of Humanities in the College of General Studies at Boston University. Her current book project examines how the ghosts in women’s supernatural fiction reflect various unspeakable social concerns of late Victorian and early twentieth-century Britain. Her research and teaching interests include Victorian and Edwardian women’s ghost stories, Victorian authors of color across the British Empire, and the intersection between digital humanities and pedagogy. Her work appears in Victorians Institute Journal Digital Annex, Preternature, The Wilkie Collins Journal, Victorian Studies, and European Romantic Review.